Every time I have had a NYC steakhouse discussion (which happens very often actually), Strip House comes up in the top of most lists. I had not been, so when I was treating a colleague to dinner, I was excited when he chose Strip House.
Strip House is on 12th Street just east of 5th Ave. There are also locations in Las Vegas, Key West, Naples (Florida), Houston, and, impressively, Livingston, NJ (In the hood where I grew up… What What!)
I failed to get a picture of the interior, but I can pretty much summarize in 2 words: Red + Leather. I also seem to remember burlesque-esque photos on the walls and a room filled with men, pretty much exclusively. Oh this was definitely a boys club.
You could smell the business transactions happening in the room.
It’s not quite my vibe (I prefer the “old style” New York feel of Keens with the old pipes hanging on the ceilings), but it was lovely to look at.
We started with the Strip House Roasted Bacon which came with baby arugula and russian dressing. The bacon was good and bacony, though I preferred the one at BLT Steak. (And is it just me, or is it somewhat strange to have this with a salad? I mean it makes sense… who doesn’t like bacon on their salad? And it’s a nice balance to have greens with the fatty bacon… but it still seemed strange to me.)
Next up we had a rib eye…
And a New York Strip.
We both preferred the Strip, and the roasted garlic on the side really made it.
The char was very good, though not the best, and I found myself wanting just a little more flavor from the meat (and using more of the roasted garlic to compensate).
For sides we ordered the Crisp Duck Fat Potatoes. I was very excited for this, but I found it VERY disappointing. It was a dome of bland potatoes with a slightly crisped outside. I had to really try to taste the duck fat. Bummer.
The other side we had was truffled creamed spinach. THIS was sensational. My favorite part of the meal.
For dessert, we had to try their famous 24-layer chocolate cake. It was good, and very rich, but it fell short simply because I’m not a big cake person. Cake to me is boring when I can have a creamy mousse or a crispy brulee. Perhaps it’s a texture thing. But as far as cake goes, this was certainly a good one!
Overall, I would say Strip House is good, but not great. It’s definitely a top steakhouse in NYC, but across the board, I’ve had better steak experiences at places like Keens, Uncle Jacks, and BLT Steak. If given the choice, I would pick any of those over Strip House. Not to say I wouldn’t go back. It just wasn’t as good as the buzz.
Total Nom Points: 7 out of 10
